ANALYSIS: Why Cadillac have stuck with Bottas for 2027

Cadillac believe experience in the cockpit is key as they look to level up in their second season in Formula 1 in 2027, which is why they have opted to keep Valtteri Bottas alongside Sergio Perez next season.

F1 Correspondent & PresenterLawrence Barretto
SAO PAULO, BRAZIL - NOVEMBER 08: Valtteri Bottas of Finland and Cadillac F1 Team talks to the media

When Cadillac announced Bottas and Perez would form their line-up for 2026, they highlighted the fact they had 527 Grands Prix and 16 victories between them was critical the call to sign the veteran duo.

The American team knew their debut in Formula 1 would be a challenge, so they wanted to tap into that immense experience. And they've needed every bit of that knowledge this year in what has turned out to be a difficult and yet point-less debut campaign.

They've struggled with reliability all year, suffering 14 DNFs - of which Bottas has had nine - and one DNS (that was Bottas), and while the performance in certain phases has raised hopes of making it into Q2 or fighting in the lower end of the midfield, it's been fleeting rather than consistent.

That's why they moved to lock down Perez on a new multi-year deal, which was announced in Mexico and will keep him at the team until at least the end of 2029.

ZANDVOORT, NETHERLANDS - AUGUST 23: Valtteri Bottas of Finland driving the (77) Cadillac F1 Team

They were then mulling whether to activate a second year of a multi-year deal with Bottas or promote American reserve driver Colton Herta to a race seat. It made sense to give this consideration given at some point, they do want to put an American driver in the car based on merit.

On pure results, Bottas has been outperformed by Perez. The Mexican leads the qualifying head-to-head 11-9 and the race head-to-head 6-1. When it comes to fastest laps, Perez is 15-3 clear and is the only one of the two to have spent time in the top-10 during a race, albeit only one lap.

'We can get rid of the noise' – Bottas after future confirmed

However, it's not really fair to compare results given that Cadillac are trying so many different things each weekend in a bid to accelerate their progress and become midfield contenders in the first instance.

It means that both drivers have not been chasing ultimate performance but rather focusing on learning about and experimenting with the car and understanding reliability issues that tend to impact brand-new teams.

LAS VEGAS, NEVADA - NOVEMBER 18: Valtteri Bottas of Finland and Cadillac F1 Team speaks in the

When you look at those metrics, which are hard to access externally, Cadillac have been very happy with what Bottas has delivered alongside Perez. They also know that with so many retirements, it's been difficult for Bottas to get any momentum or get a fair shot at showing his best self.

Looking at the overall project, they accept they need that expertise if they are to make some decent progress over the winter and into next season.

With that in mind, and in the knowledge that Bottas and Perez get on well and have worked together impressively this year, Cadillac opted to stick rather than twist and keep Bottas onboard for 2027 - and this gives 10-time winner Bottas another chance to show what he can do and keep his place for the future.

What does this mean for Herta?

It's a good question. Cadillac have heavily invested in Herta's development since bringing him over from the United States and backing him in a debut Formula 2 campaign alongside embedding him inside the F1 team through six FP1 appearances.

On the F2 side of things, life has been pretty hard. He's managed just four finishes in the points to sit 19th in the Drivers' Standings. On the F1 side, things have been better. The 26-year-old is believed to have impressed the team with the way he handled all six sessions and has shown strong progression.

MEXICO CITY, MEXICO - OCTOBER 30: Colton Herta of United States and Cadillac F1 Team looks on in

Critically, the mileage in FP1 has earned him a Super Licence that means Cadillac now have the option to put him in the car in the next few years. Time was running out to get that licence, as a big chunk of his points were set to expire at the end of this year and achieving such a big haul would be challenging next year.

We saw firsthand with Haas how tricky it was for rookie Mick Schumacher and Nikita Mazepin in 2021 to make headway and show their talent with an underdeveloped car. By putting Herta in a Cadillac now, it would have been similarly difficult and risked burning him.

GALLERY: Cadillac reveal special livery for Las Vegas

He can now focus on continuing to prepare himself for an opportunity on the grid while giving Cadillac more time to improve their overall operation.

And that wait might not be that long. There is still a chance of him stepping up in 2028 given Cadillac only confirmed Bottas for 2027.

It'll be interesting to see what Herta and Cadillac do next, with the team yet to announce their roster of test and reserve drivers for next season - but their decision gives them plenty of options going forward.

F1 Store - CadillacCheck out the latest Cadillac products in the F1 Store.SHOP NOW